Artificial intelligence (AI) is becoming more common in healthcare across the United States. It helps with clinical decisions, operations, and patient care. But using AI also brings ethical questions and challenges. Healthcare leaders need to know how to use AI responsibly. This helps ensure that AI benefits patients and staff without causing problems like bias, privacy issues, or mistrust.
One guide to help is the SHIFT framework. It was made after looking at over 253 studies on AI ethics in healthcare from 2000 to 2020. SHIFT shows how to think about responsible AI in healthcare. This article explains the five main parts of SHIFT—Sustainability, Human centeredness, Inclusiveness, Fairness, and Transparency—and how U.S. healthcare organizations can use them. We also look at AI in workflow automation and how responsible AI principles can help choose and apply these technologies.
The SHIFT framework was created by researchers including Haytham Siala and Yichuan Wang. It gives a clear way to handle ethical concerns of AI in healthcare. Each part of SHIFT helps organizations spot and solve issues so AI works well and ethically in healthcare settings.
Sustainability means building AI systems that stay useful and efficient over time. They shouldn’t waste resources or make healthcare inequalities worse. In U.S. healthcare, this means picking AI that uses resources carefully and can change with clinical needs and rules. It also means investing in data systems that protect privacy and support ongoing AI updates. AI should not become too expensive or old-fashioned in busy medical places.
Medical leaders should think about how AI fits with cybersecurity and IT upkeep. AI tools must work well now and be easy to update or grow without needing too much new money. Sustainable AI avoids adding extra work for healthcare staff and helps get the most value from technology.
Human centeredness means putting people first when designing, using, and watching AI. The American Medical Association calls this “augmented intelligence.” AI should help doctors and healthcare staff, not replace them.
This means AI should support doctors’ decisions, respect patient rights, and keep care safe. For example, AI can improve diagnosis or cut back routine admin tasks, so doctors spend more time with patients. It is important to be clear with patients when AI is used in their care and explain how decisions are made and data is used.
Medical leaders benefit from involving clinical staff when choosing and using AI. This ensures AI meets real needs and does not disturb the work flow or doctors’ independence. The AMA supports training programs to prepare doctors for using AI. This helps build trust and keeps AI use ethical.
Inclusiveness means making AI work fairly for all patients and not increase healthcare differences. Sometimes AI is biased because it is trained on data that does not represent everyone well. This can lead to unfair care.
In the U.S., AI must be tested on groups with different races, ethnicities, genders, ages, and incomes to make sure it is fair. Healthcare leaders should ask AI vendors to prove their tools are inclusive and that they work to reduce bias.
It is also important to involve many people—patients, doctors, ethicists, and community members—in designing and overseeing AI tools. This helps prevent harm to vulnerable groups and improves AI fairness.
Fairness means making sure AI does not show bias or treat any group unfairly. Biased AI can cause unequal care, which is not acceptable.
To keep AI fair, systems should be regularly checked for bias. Diverse data should be used to build AI, and the way AI makes decisions should be open and clear. Healthcare leaders need to make fairness a top priority when picking AI and ask vendors for proof of bias control.
Fairness also means informing patients and getting their consent about AI in their care. This builds trust and helps healthcare work better.
Transparency means making AI processes, decisions, and data use clear to users, doctors, patients, and regulators. Without this, AI can become a “black box,” where no one knows how it works. This can cause mistrust or misuse.
The AMA says transparency is key for AI ethics in healthcare. Doctors and leaders should know where AI algorithms come from, their limits, and how they decide. Good documentation, model explanations, and regular reports help keep AI responsible.
Transparency also helps meet U.S. laws like HIPAA, which protect patient privacy. Transparent AI governance includes watching for problems and using user feedback to improve AI over time.
AI is helping front-office work in healthcare, such as phone systems and answering services. Companies like Simbo AI offer AI solutions that change how clinics handle calls, appointments, and patient questions.
Using AI in front-office tasks can reduce staff workload, improve patient contact, and increase efficiency. However, it is important to use AI responsibly, following SHIFT principles.
Human Centeredness and Transparency are key here. AI answering systems should clearly show when patients are talking to a machine and let them easily reach a human if needed. This respects patient wishes and keeps trust. Simbo AI can customize technology to communicate clearly and reduce frustration.
Inclusiveness means designing AI language and interaction styles that work for diverse patients, including those with disabilities or who speak limited English. Fairness means AI should not favor certain patients by routing calls or recognizing language better for some groups.
Sustainability means AI solutions should fit with current practice management systems and cause little disruption when added. They should grow easily as patient numbers or needs change.
Administrators should choose tools that provide clear reports on AI accuracy, error rates, and patient satisfaction to help improve AI and meet standards.
Research shows that strong AI governance is needed in healthcare. Good governance includes organizational rules, involvement of stakeholders, and clear procedures to manage AI from design to use and ongoing checks.
Healthcare leaders should create policies about AI use, train staff, and keep oversight systems in place. Governance must make sure AI follows laws, including FDA rules for clinical AI and HIPAA for data privacy.
As AI spreads fast in healthcare, organizations must not only adopt technology but also set up accountability. Regular audits, ethics boards, and groups with different experts help watch AI effects. This reduces risks of bias, unclear operation, and patient safety problems.
Data from the American Medical Association shows AI use among U.S. doctors rose from 38% in 2023 to 66% in 2024. More doctors now see benefits in using AI. Still, challenges remain. Doctors want more proof that AI works well, clearer guidance on how to use it, and help to lower extra work caused by it.
Programs like AMA’s STEPS Forward® offer resources and continuing education to help doctors and leaders use AI carefully. These programs cover how to fit AI into the workflow, ethics, and doctor well-being. The AMA also plans to start a Center for Digital Health and AI in 2025 to support AI development led by doctors, ensuring AI tools are practical and ethical.
For healthcare practices in the U.S., these trends show opportunities and responsibilities. Leaders must carefully check AI tools, focusing on ethics, inclusiveness, and openness to provide good care while managing new technology well.
By using the SHIFT framework and strong governance, healthcare leaders can bring AI into their work in a way that improves efficiency and patient care. At the same time, it keeps ethical and legal standards in place. This balance helps build trust and provide quality care as AI becomes a bigger part of healthcare.
The core ethical concerns include data privacy, algorithmic bias, fairness, transparency, inclusiveness, and ensuring human-centeredness in AI systems to prevent harm and maintain trust in healthcare delivery.
The study reviewed 253 articles published between 2000 and 2020, using the PRISMA approach for systematic review and meta-analysis, coupled with a hermeneutic approach to synthesize themes and knowledge.
SHIFT stands for Sustainability, Human centeredness, Inclusiveness, Fairness, and Transparency, guiding AI developers, healthcare professionals, and policymakers toward ethical and responsible AI deployment.
Human centeredness ensures that AI technologies prioritize patient wellbeing, respect autonomy, and support healthcare professionals, keeping humans at the core of AI decision-making rather than replacing them.
Inclusiveness addresses the need to consider diverse populations to avoid biased AI outcomes, ensuring equitable healthcare access and treatment across different demographic, ethnic, and social groups.
Transparency facilitates trust by making AI algorithms’ workings understandable to users and stakeholders, allowing detection and correction of bias, and ensuring accountability in healthcare decisions.
Sustainability relates to developing AI solutions that are resource-efficient, maintain long-term effectiveness, and are adaptable to evolving healthcare needs without exacerbating inequalities or resource depletion.
Bias can lead to unfair treatment and health disparities. Addressing it requires diverse data sets, inclusive algorithm design, regular audits, and continuous stakeholder engagement to ensure fairness.
Investments are needed for data infrastructure that protects privacy, development of ethical AI frameworks, training healthcare professionals, and fostering multi-disciplinary collaborations that drive innovation responsibly.
Future research should focus on advancing governance models, refining ethical frameworks like SHIFT, exploring scalable transparency practices, and developing tools for bias detection and mitigation in clinical AI systems.
Simbo is using AI agents to automate all phone related workflows. Connect now to know more.
Schedule AI Agents Demo Now© Since 2019, Simbo AI.
