Doctors in the United States often spend about two hours a day on paperwork outside of office hours. This extra work can make doctors feel tired and leaves less time to see patients. It also costs the healthcare system about $4.6 billion every year because of these inefficiencies.
Most of this work comes from entering detailed notes into electronic health records (EHRs), managing messages, and meeting billing rules. Because of this, many doctors are starting to use AI-based medical scribes to help with documentation. In 2024, 66% of doctors in the US used AI tools for clinical notes, which is a 78% increase from 2023.
Since many doctors are adopting these tools quickly, it is important to choose the right AI medical scribe systems. These systems need to work with different specialties, fit doctor workflows, and follow privacy rules like HIPAA.
One large evaluation of AI medical scribe systems was done by the Cleveland Clinic in 2024. They tested five AI scribe products in over 80 specialties and subspecialties. About 25 to 35 doctors tried each system for three to five months. This helped to see how the technology worked in different medical settings.
The Cleveland Clinic looked at several important points when testing:
The Clinic included many doctors in the evaluation, focusing not just on technology but also on how well it fit their work and culture. Rohit Chandra, the chief digital officer, said that this was “a health care play more than a tech play,” meaning the AI must meet doctors’ actual needs.
Doctors had to review and approve AI notes before signing them to keep quality high. Patients were told about the use of AI and could choose not to use it. This helped keep trust and transparency.
After the tests, Cleveland Clinic selected Ambience Healthcare’s AI platform. This system was strong in note quality, workflow fit, and helped reduce paperwork so doctors could spend more time with patients.
Some recent trends help explain how AI medical scribes are used in the US:
Because of these factors, the AI documentation market in the US is expected to grow from $2.5 billion in 2024 to over $6.6 billion by 2031.
Large health groups like The Permanente Medical Group use AI scribes millions of times each year. This shows AI helps with workflow efficiency and makes both doctors and patients more satisfied.
Large Language Models (LLMs) are a type of AI that can understand and write text like humans. They are a good base for AI medical scribes. These models have some key abilities:
To use LLMs well, designers must create easy-to-use tools and train doctors on how to work with the AI. Doctors should check AI results carefully to keep notes accurate.
Ethics are also important. LLMs must protect patient privacy, avoid bias, and show clearly how notes were created by AI. Doctors must supervise AI, and patients should agree to AI use.
AI medical scribes also help by automating parts of clinical work. This automation makes routine, time-consuming tasks faster.
Important features include:
This reduces “pajama time,” which is when doctors finish notes late at night. Studies show after-hours documentation can drop by 30% to 50% with these tools. Note accuracy also gets better over time.
IT managers should pick AI systems that connect smoothly with EHRs using APIs. This helps keep work running without interruption while improving efficiency.
When medical clinics plan to use AI scribes, they need a clear way to measure success. Important factors to check are:
The Cleveland Clinic’s pilot shows the value of involving doctors closely and keeping patients informed and able to choose AI use. This builds trust and helps new technology fit smoothly into care.
AI medical scribes must work across many medical fields with very different needs. For example:
Because of this variety, AI scribes must be adjustable for each specialty. They should learn special medical terms, codes, and note styles. AI that keeps learning from doctor input gets better over time and suits specialties more closely.
These features help doctors focus on caring for patients rather than paperwork.
Even with AI, human checks are needed to keep note quality and patient safety high. Doctors must review AI notes before finalizing them to catch any mistakes or missing details.
Patients need to know when AI is used and should be able to say no if they want. This respects their privacy and choice.
Healthcare groups must protect data by following national rules and signing agreements with AI vendors. Staff training on privacy is also important to reduce risks.
AI medical scribes can improve note quality, work speed, and patient care. But health leaders must choose and use these tools carefully. Pilot testing in many specialties, involving doctors, and collecting clear data are key steps.
For clinics and health systems with many specialties, AI tools must fit different workflows and connect well with EHRs. It is also important that the technology matches the culture and values of the medical team, as Cleveland Clinic showed.
AI will keep improving in accuracy, understanding context, and automating tasks. With careful evaluation and use, doctors and health systems in the US can get better efficiency and care through AI medical scribes.
Cleveland Clinic conducted a rigorous pilot program testing five AI medical scribe systems across over 80 specialties and subspecialties. They involved 25 to 35 clinicians per system for 3 to 5 months, analyzing documentation quality, product features, provider satisfaction, ease of implementation, and return on investment using data from Epic, provider surveys, patient feedback, and technical evaluations.
Cleveland Clinic emphasized the culture and fit of AI vendors across specialties, prioritizing passion for health care over just technology capabilities. They viewed AI scribing as impacting clinical workflows and provider-patient interaction, requiring alignment with healthcare values, needs, and clinician engagement rather than merely adopting new tech.
Providers are required to review, confirm, and edit AI-generated notes for accuracy and completeness before signing. Though ambulatory providers can opt to use the tool voluntarily, full engagement is critical for documentation quality and ensuring trust in AI-generated clinical records.
AI scribes are expected to substantially reduce documentation burdens, allowing providers to focus more on patient care, operate at the top of their license, and improve physician-patient interactions, ultimately enhancing provider satisfaction and healthcare delivery quality.
Cleveland Clinic chose Ambience Healthcare’s AI platform for documentation, clinical documentation integrity, and point-of-care coding, as it demonstrated strong documentation quality, workflow integration, and the potential to reduce clinician administrative workload while enhancing patient interaction time.
Patients were notified before the AI tool was used during visits, with the option to opt out, ensuring transparency and respecting patient autonomy in the adoption of ambient AI documentation technologies.
The pilot encompassed over 80 specialties and subspecialties, reflecting a broad and diverse clinical spectrum to thoroughly assess the AI technology’s adaptability and efficacy across different practice areas.
Evaluation metrics included documentation quality, product features, provider satisfaction, implementation ease, and return on investment, using Epic electronic health record data, provider survey feedback, patient input, and technical system assessments.
The AI scribe technology is considered ‘amazing’ currently and is expected to continue improving, enabling further reductions in administrative burdens, enhancing provider experience, and improving documentation quality and patient care interactions over time.
By involving a sizable group of clinicians in evaluations and emphasizing vendor passion for healthcare, Cleveland Clinic ensured AI vendors aligned culturally and operationally across various specialties, fostering smoother adoption and sustained use.
Simbo is using AI agents to automate all phone related workflows. Connect now to know more.
Schedule AI Agents Demo Now© Since 2019, Simbo AI.
