The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) has rules to keep patients’ health information private and safe in the United States. For people running medical offices or managing IT, it is important to know about criminal liability under HIPAA. Breaking HIPAA rules can lead to big fines and criminal charges. Data breaches can cause serious problems for healthcare groups. This article explains the difference between knowledge and intent in HIPAA violations, how criminal liability works, and how data breaches hurt healthcare organizations. It also talks about how AI and automation can help reduce risks.
HIPAA violations happen when someone does not follow the rules for protecting patient health information (called PHI). Some violations lead to civil fines, but serious ones can lead to criminal charges. Criminal liability happens when a person or group knowingly gets or shares PHI without permission with some level of knowledge and intent.
The idea of “knowingly” is important in criminal cases. The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) says “knowingly” means the person knows what they are doing when getting or sharing PHI. This does NOT mean they must know it breaks HIPAA laws. This is important because even if they did not mean to break the law, they can still face criminal penalties if they knew they were handling PHI wrongly without permission.
For example, if a healthcare worker looks at PHI without permission and shares it, they can be charged even if they did not plan to break the law. But the intent does affect how severe the punishment is.
There are different levels of criminal penalties depending on what the person wanted to do. These affect fines and jail time:
Tier 3 cases often involve selling medical records or using them for fraud or identity theft. These punishments show the government takes this very seriously.
Civil fines handle many HIPAA violations. But big or intentional breaches can lead to criminal charges. Civil fines are handled by the Office for Civil Rights (OCR) under Health and Human Services (HHS). Fines depend on how careless or serious the problem was and if it was fixed:
These fines often come with requirements like staff training, better safeguards, or changes to privacy rules. If violations aren’t fixed quickly, fines can become larger.
Violations become breaches when PHI is accessed, used, or shared without permission, harming privacy or security. Breaches are part of violations but have their own rules and penalties.
Organizations must tell HHS and affected people about breaches involving unsecured PHI within 60 days of finding it. If a breach affects 500 or more people in one state, the organization must also tell the media. If fewer than 500 people are affected, the breach is reported once a year to HHS.
These rules help keep things open and let people take steps to protect themselves from identity theft or fraud.
Breaches have stronger legal effects than accidental violations. Besides fines, breaches often lead to investigations, requirements to fix problems, and closer watchdog oversight. They may hurt the organization’s reputation and cause financial losses from lawsuits or losing patient trust.
In 2023, HHS recorded 725 breaches affecting over 133 million patients. About 66% involved people inside the organization. This shows why internal controls and staff awareness are important.
Covered entities under HIPAA include healthcare providers, health plans, and clearinghouses that send claims electronically. They are mainly responsible for protecting PHI and following the rules.
Also, officers, directors, employees, and business associates working with PHI can be held criminally or civilly liable. This means individuals, not just organizations, face penalties for breaking HIPAA rules. For example, Jennifer Lynne Bacor, a patient care technician, was fined and put on probation for repeatedly looking at her ex-boyfriend’s PHI without permission.
Groups must also have strict policies to avoid penalties and keep their ability to work with Medicare. Not following rules may result in being stopped from participating in Medicare, which can hurt a healthcare organization financially and operationally.
Because HIPAA rules are strict and data breach risks grow, healthcare groups in the U.S. are using technology to help. Artificial Intelligence (AI) and workflow automation can reduce mistakes and make handling patient information easier and safer.
Simbo AI is a company that uses AI to automate front-office phone tasks. In medical offices, front-office jobs like scheduling, checking information, and answering questions often involve PHI. Using AI for these tasks can lower the chance of mistakes that lead to improper sharing.
Automated phone systems with HIPAA rules built in can:
This can reduce accidental violations from talking at the front desk.
Automation tools also help inside the organization to manage PHI safely:
These tools make dealing with HIPAA rules simpler and reduce depending on humans who can make errors.
People running medical offices or IT must understand how knowledge, intent, and breaches affect HIPAA penalties. Knowing the difference between civil and criminal fines and what counts as a breach helps organizations plan data security and staff training.
With insider breaches growing and fines rising, using AI and automation like Simbo AI’s phone system and workflow tools is helpful. These efforts protect patient data, lower legal risks, and keep healthcare organizations running smoothly in the U.S.
This kind of knowledge helps healthcare workers guard their organizations from serious legal and money problems caused by HIPAA violations and criminal liability.
The OCR is responsible for enforcing the HIPAA Privacy and Security Rules. It investigates complaints, conducts compliance reviews, and performs education and outreach to ensure covered entities comply with HIPAA.
In cases of noncompliance, the OCR seeks voluntary compliance, corrective action, or resolution agreements. If unsatisfied, it may impose civil monetary penalties (CMPs).
CMPs are determined based on a tiered structure reflecting the violation’s severity. Penalties can range from $100 to $50,000 per violation, with annual maximums for repeat violations.
Penalties vary based on the violation’s nature: $100-$50,000 for unknowing violations; $1,000-$50,000 for reasonable cause; $10,000-$50,000 for willful neglect if corrected; and $50,000 for willful neglect if uncorrected.
Criminal violations are addressed by the DOJ, with varying penalties. Knowingly obtaining or disclosing health information can lead to fines up to $50,000 and imprisonment.
The DOJ interprets ‘knowingly’ as awareness of the actions involved in a violation, not necessarily understanding that those actions contravene HIPAA.
Covered entities include health plans, health care clearinghouses, and health care providers who transmit claims electronically. Officers and employees may also face liability under corporate criminal liability.
If offenses are committed under false pretenses, individuals may face fines up to $100,000 and imprisonment of up to five years.
Violations committed with intent to sell or exploit health information can incur fines of $250,000 and imprisonment of up to ten years.
HHS can exclude noncompliant covered entities from Medicare participation if they failed to adhere to transaction and code set standards by the established deadline.
Simbo is using AI agents to automate all phone related workflows. Connect now to know more.
Schedule AI Agents Demo Now© Since 2019, Simbo AI.
