Before talking about contract terms, doctors and practice leaders need to figure out what “market value” means. Market value is the fair and usual pay a doctor should get based on their specialty, experience, place, and demand. This idea is part of federal rules like the Stark Law and the Anti-Kickback Statute. These rules say pay must match Fair Market Value (FMV). FMV means paying without thinking about the number of patient referrals to avoid conflicts of interest.
Finding market value is not simple. It uses many data sources, legal rules, and local market conditions. These change a lot depending on where the doctor works, their specialty, and the healthcare group’s finances.
Medical groups often use pay surveys and reports to help. Examples include the Medical Group Management Association (MGMA), Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC), Sullivan Cotter Associates (SCA), and industry platforms like Doximity and Medscape. Among these, the MGMA survey is most often used because it has many responses and detailed data by region and specialty. Each year, MGMA collects about 1,000 to 2,000 responses, covering around 10% of those asked. It breaks down data by area, specialty, and years of practice.
But these surveys do have limits. Many only cover a very small part of all doctors in the country—less than 1%. Often, their data is one or two years old. They might not fully show local economic changes, new healthcare policy, or special practice setups. Also, Medscape uses self-reported data from about 13,000 people, which might be biased.
Because of this, doctors and managers should use these surveys as guides, not absolute answers. Knowing how your employer figures out FMV, including what data they use, is important to judge if job offers or contracts fairly match current market conditions.
Going into contract talks without knowing your market value can affect your pay and career for a long time. Research by Michael Johnson Legal shows many doctors accept pay below market rates because they don’t have enough facts or training to negotiate well. This can especially happen with new hires or locum tenens contracts, which set the baseline for future pay.
Knowing your market value gives you power in talks. Doctors who know proper salary and work benchmarks can argue for fair pay. This knowledge helps with other contract parts too, like ownership chances, call duties, benefits, non-compete rules, and contract end terms.
Checking market value can show warning signs like:
Knowing these parts helps you make smart decisions and avoid contract terms that hurt your career freedom or money security.
Employment contracts for doctors are complex and cover more than salary. Knowing market value well helps with negotiating:
Knowing pay and benefit benchmarks lets you focus negotiations on what matters and understand what is realistic. Without this, doctors might accept too-low pay or contracts that limit them.
David W. Hilgers, a healthcare lawyer with experience in doctor contract talks, says groups should honestly and clearly evaluate their value before negotiating with hospitals, health plans, or Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs). This review should look at:
Hilgers suggests collecting proof like national pay surveys and internal finances to support negotiating positions. Goals should be clear, agreed on by the group, and flexible enough to handle offers without losing bargaining strength.
Also, knowing the effects of saying no to an offer and going out-of-network can be a good tactic. Patient complaints may push employers or hospitals back to talk. Understanding this local situation and finding allies inside or outside helps get better results.
Legal advice is important through all this. Lawyers familiar with employment laws and doctor contracts make sure proposals follow rules and stop clauses that could put doctors or groups at risk.
Where a doctor works has a big effect on pay. Rural or underserved places often pay higher salaries and offer loan forgiveness to get doctors, while cities may have better lifestyle options but sometimes lower pay. Wage differences of 20% to 40% exist between academic, hospital-employed, and private groups.
Specialty also affects pay types. Procedure-based specialties like surgery or cardiology usually get paid more for productivity with higher wRVU rates. Primary care often has a mix of patient panel pay, quality rewards, and base salary.
IT managers and administrators who manage many sites should know these differences when budgeting or hiring. Knowing pay differences helps keep good doctors and avoid losing them to better offers.
Technology, like artificial intelligence (AI) and workflow automation, is starting to change how medical groups handle doctor contracts and admin work.
AI tools can quickly check contracts for bad terms, legal risks, or mistakes. They use language processing to read complex legal papers, point out risky non-compete rules, unclear bonuses, or tough workload demands. For medical managers and owners, these tools cut down the need for outside legal reviews, saving time and money.
AI can collect large amounts of market data from sources like MGMA, AMGA, SCA, and others, and make reports based on a doctor’s specialty, region, and practice. By combining local pay rates, work benchmarks, and usual contract terms, AI gives tailored market value reports. This helps doctors and managers negotiate confidently and smartly.
Automated systems help with creating, reviewing, approving, and renewing contracts. For managers handling many doctor contracts, automation tracks deadlines, renegotiation times, and legal rules, cutting admin work and risks of missing dates.
This technology, though not directly about contracts, improves practice efficiency. Automating patient calls, appointments, and questions frees clinical staff to focus on care and admin tasks, including contract communications or recruiting. Better operations can help negotiations by showing a smooth, well-run practice.
For IT managers, using AI contract and workflow tools fits wider goals of controlling costs, managing risks, and improving provider workflows. This tech helps better financial plans and supports data-based doctor contracting that fits real market conditions.
Locum tenens doctors—temporary or fill-in providers—face special challenges when figuring market value. Their contracts are less standard and benchmarks are fewer. Healthcare lawyer Dennis Hursh says to use a “replacement cost” method. This counts all costs: base pay, bonuses, benefits, and employer overhead to find a fair hourly rate.
Locum pay should at least match or slightly go above regular doctor hourly costs to reflect temporary and flexible service. Hospitals often cite rules like the Stark Law to limit pay, but Hursh says doctors should think about the hospital’s “opportunity cost”—lost patient revenue and referrals when there is no coverage.
For managers and owners, knowing FMV for locums helps keep budgets in check and pay rates competitive. Paying fairly improves care quality and continuity, lowering costs from turnover or staff shortages.
Medical practice managers, owners, and IT staff should help doctors get ready for negotiations by:
A doctor who is well informed and supported by management has a better chance to get contract terms that match pay benchmarks, fair workload, and good benefits.
Medical groups in the United States should use steady market value reviews and tech tools to improve doctor contract talks. This approach helps keep staff steady, control labor costs, and supports long-term group goals.
Key components include compensation and bonuses, benefits, work schedule and call duties, termination clauses, non-compete clauses, and partnership or ownership opportunities.
Knowing your market value, influenced by specialty, location, experience, and demand, gives you leverage in negotiations to secure a fair compensation package.
Compensation structures include salary-only, productivity-based, and hybrid models, each having its pros and cons regarding income potential and financial risk.
Non-compete clauses can limit future job options. It’s crucial to negotiate for shorter durations, smaller geographic areas, or removal.
Termination provisions can be ‘without cause’ (with notice) or ‘for cause’ (under specific conditions), and should protect your interests.
A strong benefits package adds significant value to your overall compensation, affecting health insurance, malpractice insurance, retirement plans, and continuing education.
Professional advice from an attorney can help decode complex legal language, identify red flags, and negotiate favorable terms.
Factors include specialty, geographic location, years of experience, and market demand which can all affect salary and bonuses.
The hybrid model combines a base salary with productivity bonuses, balancing stability with the potential for higher earnings.
‘Cause’ can include breach of contract or failure to meet performance metrics, and should be clearly defined in the contract.
Simbo is using AI agents to automate all phone related workflows. Connect now to know more.
Schedule AI Agents Demo Now© Since 2019, Simbo AI.
