Horizontal consolidation happens when hospitals or health systems that do the same kind of work merge or join together. The goal is to get a bigger part of the market, lower competition, and make bigger health systems.
For example, in 2015, Stanford Health Care merged with ValleyCare Health System. This created a bigger network that could serve more people across a larger area. In 2020, Atrium Health and Wake Forest Baptist Health joined to become one of the biggest hospital systems in the U.S. Together, they cover 42 hospitals in four states and expect to make $11 billion. These merges help hospitals grow and compete better.
Increased Market Share: Hospitals grow their patient base and can enter new areas.
Improved Negotiating Power: Larger systems have more strength when dealing with insurance companies and suppliers, which can help with prices and payments.
Economies of Scale: By sharing resources like administration and technology, hospitals can lower costs per patient.
Expanded Service Offerings: Merging can let hospitals add new kinds of care that smaller hospitals might not offer.
Horizontal merges can make hospitals work more efficiently, but research shows they often raise healthcare prices. For example, a study in California found that when hospital market concentration went up by 10%, the price for cesarean births without problems went up by 1.3%. The Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) is used to measure how concentrated a market is. Scores above 2,500 mean less competition.
California’s experience shows that bigger hospital systems reduce competition, which gives them more power to negotiate with insurers. This usually leads to higher prices for patients and those who pay for care.
Vertical consolidation happens when hospitals merge with healthcare groups that operate at different points in patient care. For example, hospitals may buy doctor’s offices, clinics, or specialty pharmacies. This puts many services under one organization.
From 2010 to 2018, the number of doctors’ offices owned by hospitals in California grew a lot. Ownership of primary care doctors grew from 24% to 42%, and ownership of specialists went from 25% to 52%. This shows hospitals want to control more parts of patient care, which can improve how care is coordinated.
Improved Care Coordination: When doctors and hospitals are part of the same system, it can make referrals, treatment plans, and sharing medical records easier.
Financial Stability: Small or struggling doctor’s offices get help from big hospital systems, such as money, infrastructure, and better contracts with insurers.
Increased Market Power: Vertical consolidation lets both hospitals and doctors negotiate better deals, which can raise prices by limiting insurer choices.
Operational Efficiency: Combining outpatient and hospital services can make workflows smoother and cut down repeated work, often helped by technology.
Vertical consolidation can improve care and coordination, but it often raises healthcare costs. Studies in California show that when hospitals own doctor offices, health insurance premiums and out-of-pocket costs tend to go up. Fewer competitors in the market can drive prices higher.
This kind of consolidation can also lead to closing less profitable services or lowering attention to community needs, especially in rural areas. For example, between 2010 and 2018, one in eight rural hospitals merged with health systems outside their area. While these merges provide financial help, they may reduce local control.
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Department of Justice (DOJ) watch hospital mergers closely. They want to stop deals that could hurt patients by raising prices or lowering access. Both horizontal and vertical merges face review. Mergers between companies in different geographic areas also get special attention because they have less direct competition.
In recent years, regulators have been more active. For example, in 2022, the FTC stopped several hospital merges over worries about higher prices and lower care quality. California’s attorney general has set rules for cross-market merges, like price caps and service limits to protect consumers. In 2023, the FTC’s draft guidelines included language about vertical and cross-market deals, signaling more oversight ahead.
Hospital managers and practice owners need to think about these rules and do careful legal reviews before making merger plans.
Making hospital mergers work well depends a lot on combining technology systems smoothly. Cloud platforms, resource planning software, electronic health records (EHR), and supply chain tools are important to handle bigger and more complex health systems.
Almost 45% of healthcare organizations now use cloud-based supply chain systems. Hospitals like Prisma Health and Rady Children’s Hospital improved their efficiency by linking supply chain information and automating buying processes with cloud solutions.
Simbo AI offers a good example of how artificial intelligence helps healthcare during mergers. It automates front-office phone calls and answers patient questions with AI. This makes handling more patients and scheduling appointments easier and faster.
AI answering services help by quickly booking appointments, answering patient questions, and doing routine tasks without delays. This means less work for front desk staff, shorter wait times, and better patient experience, which is important as hospital systems get bigger through mergers.
For IT managers and healthcare leaders, using AI tools like Simbo AI helps improve communication, make workflows smoother, and lower operating costs. It also helps manage resources better across different locations.
Both horizontal and vertical mergers create new challenges for administrators and IT workers in medical practices:
For Administrators: Mergers bring changes in culture, staff roles, and the need to align clinical and financial goals. They must handle contract renegotiations, watch service changes, and follow rules about competition.
For IT Managers: Bringing technology systems together is a big task. This includes moving to shared EHRs, securing data platforms, adopting cloud supply chains, and using AI for patient communication. IT staff must make sure technology helps consolidation without causing problems in care.
Vertical merges are usually more complex for IT because they combine different care levels. It takes detailed planning to link doctor offices’ data with hospital systems safely and with room to grow.
Cost Reductions: Hospitals that join others often cut their operating costs by about 3.3% per patient. They may also see a 3.7% drop in patient revenue per admission. This suggests they become more efficient by growing.
Quality Improvements: When mergers are fully combined, patient outcomes improve in common cases like heart attacks, heart failure, stroke, and pneumonia.
Increased Readmission Rates: On the downside, heart patients may return to the hospital 10-12% more often after mergers, which can show trouble with care continuity.
Supply Chain Savings: Groups like RWJBarnabas saved nearly $2 million by standardizing clinical care and supplies using collaboration and technology.
Many small or struggling hospitals seek mergers to survive. Consolidation is an important way for them to stay open. Still, it is hard to balance better operations, patient care quality, and fair pricing.
Healthcare merges in the U.S. mainly fall into two kinds: horizontal, where similar organizations merge, and vertical, where organizations at different care stages join. Both types help with bigger market presence, better care integration, and operational improvement, but they also often raise healthcare prices and reduce competition.
Medical practice managers and IT staff need to know the rules, use cloud and AI tools like Simbo AI, and plan carefully to handle these changes well. Technology makes transitions smoother and patient care better as merges keep changing healthcare systems.
Knowing how these changes happen is important for managing and succeeding in today’s healthcare world.
Key drivers include economies of scale, revenue generation, competitive advantage, and the need to expand service lines. Financial pressure often compels financially distressed hospitals to merge with larger health systems to remain operational and access new markets.
There are two main types: horizontal consolidation, where similar healthcare entities merge, and vertical mergers, involving different services. Private equity investment is also on the rise in healthcare M&A.
M&As can lead to reduced operating costs, improved quality of care, and enhanced access to services. Acquired hospitals often see better patient outcomes and the introduction of new services.
M&A can lead to higher costs, worse patient experiences, increased readmission rates, and restricted healthcare access, especially in rural areas. Regulatory scrutiny around antitrust laws is also a concern.
Technology, particularly cloud-based solutions, facilitates seamless integration of supply chain processes, improving operational efficiency and supporting decision-making through data sharing and automation.
Critical components include integrating enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems, charge masters, electronic health records (EHR), item masters, and procurement processes to streamline operations.
Cloud technology enhances efficiency in supply chain processes, automates procure-to-pay transactions, provides real-time inventory management, and integrates clinical and financial data, thereby optimizing care quality and cost.
Healthcare organizations must conduct a thorough antitrust analysis and risk evaluation, as regulators like the FTC are increasingly scrutinizing proposed mergers for potential negative impacts on prices and quality.
The financial struggles exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic have driven many hospitals to pursue mergers. Additionally, there is a marked transition from acute care to non-acute care settings.
Executives should focus on cultural alignment, robust leadership involvement, understanding regulatory perspectives, and the adoption of technology to address integration challenges effectively.
Simbo is using AI agents to automate all phone related workflows. Connect now to know more.
Schedule AI Agents Demo Now© Since 2019, Simbo AI.
